The Fix • Analysis
Trump’s approval hits 50 percent — in a doctored poll graphic shared by his son
By Avi Selk
August 10 at 12:33 PM PT
(Instagram/Screen capture)
Donald Trump Jr. shared a doctored image that makes his father's Gallup presidential approval rating look 10 points higher than it actually is — surprising even people who have otherwise become numb to factual distortions from Trump's inner circle.
Trump Jr. did not acknowledge countless requests to correct the obviously manipulated image after he posted it to Instagram late Wednesday. It was deleted Friday afternoon, by which time tens of thousands of people had seen, shared or endorsed his father's bogus 50 percent approval rating.
Here, as best we can piece together, is how the fakery started.
The image was originally a still frame from a CNN video that aired this week. Ironically, the network had been attempting to fact-check President Trump's recent claim that he had “better [approval] numbers than Obama at this point, by far.”
So CNN's John King pulled up a graphic based on Gallup's presidential approval polls and various economic measures. While Trump outperformed his predecessor in terms of the deficit, employment rates and gross domestic product (Barack Obama became president during a deep recession, King noted), he clearly lagged behind Obama on the top line:
Trump had a 40 percent approval rating, compared with Obama's 45 percent at the same point in his presidency.
King was hardly the first reporter to disprove one of Trump's polling boasts, but the CNN segment annoyed many of the president's hardcore supporters. “Trump is near 50% approval. CNN is absolute Fake news,” reads a typical complaint on Reddit's far-right “The_Donald” board.
Something like a consensus formed on that forum — Trump's real approval rating ought to be 50 percent. No one cited any data. Maybe they were recalling outlier polls that have put Trump's numbers higher, like several from Rasmussen Reports, which the president tends to cherry pick and promote. Maybe they were following an axiom that Trump once put forward: “Whatever Trump's poll number is, add nine.”
In any case, someone soon pasted a “50%” where CNN's “40%” had been, and the crudely doctored freeze frame began to spread across the Trump Internet.
“Trumps doing big things people! No one can take him down!” wrote an Instagram user who shared the image several hours before it ended up on Trump Jr.'s page, in front of his 1.2 million followers.
“Amazing,” Trump Jr. wrote. “I guess there is a magic wand to make things happen and @realdonaldtrump seems to have it. #MAGA #amreicafirst.”
The initial surge of comments that followed Trump Jr.'s post were overwhelmingly positive — Trump fans thrilled at the president's inflated approval rate.
But within minutes, people began to inform Trump Jr. that something was wrong.
“Yes, that 'magic wand' is Photoshop's Magic Wand tool,” chrisconradie1 wrote to Trump Jr., referring to the software of choice for fake photo makers. Re-creation below:
(Re-creation/Adobe Photoshop/The Washington Post)
Quite a few people noticed that this wasn't even a quality hoax.
The "50%” was misaligned with the text on the original CNN graphic, and its background was a different shade of red. Also, by zooming in one could see that the original "40%” was still visible underneath the fake number.
It's still unclear how Trump Jr. found the fake image, or why he decided to share it, or left it up for a day and a half. Neither he nor a representative responded to questions from The Washington Post sent Friday morning — but by mid afternoon the bogus image had disappeared from his Instagram account.
The articles has been updated since Trump Jr. removed the image.
Read more:
Trump’s comparison of his popularity to Obama’s is less wrong than it used to be
A Reddit user who wrote about stabbing Muslims is claiming credit for Trump’s CNN video
The Trump presidency: 544 days of weird glowing orb photos
Avi Selk is a general assignment reporter for The Washington Post. He previously worked for the Dallas Morning News.
Democracy Dies in Darkness
Trump’s approval hits 50 percent — in a doctored poll graphic shared by his son
By Avi Selk
August 10 at 12:33 PM PT
(Instagram/Screen capture)
Donald Trump Jr. shared a doctored image that makes his father's Gallup presidential approval rating look 10 points higher than it actually is — surprising even people who have otherwise become numb to factual distortions from Trump's inner circle.
Trump Jr. did not acknowledge countless requests to correct the obviously manipulated image after he posted it to Instagram late Wednesday. It was deleted Friday afternoon, by which time tens of thousands of people had seen, shared or endorsed his father's bogus 50 percent approval rating.
Here, as best we can piece together, is how the fakery started.
The image was originally a still frame from a CNN video that aired this week. Ironically, the network had been attempting to fact-check President Trump's recent claim that he had “better [approval] numbers than Obama at this point, by far.”
So CNN's John King pulled up a graphic based on Gallup's presidential approval polls and various economic measures. While Trump outperformed his predecessor in terms of the deficit, employment rates and gross domestic product (Barack Obama became president during a deep recession, King noted), he clearly lagged behind Obama on the top line:
Trump had a 40 percent approval rating, compared with Obama's 45 percent at the same point in his presidency.
King was hardly the first reporter to disprove one of Trump's polling boasts, but the CNN segment annoyed many of the president's hardcore supporters. “Trump is near 50% approval. CNN is absolute Fake news,” reads a typical complaint on Reddit's far-right “The_Donald” board.
Something like a consensus formed on that forum — Trump's real approval rating ought to be 50 percent. No one cited any data. Maybe they were recalling outlier polls that have put Trump's numbers higher, like several from Rasmussen Reports, which the president tends to cherry pick and promote. Maybe they were following an axiom that Trump once put forward: “Whatever Trump's poll number is, add nine.”
In any case, someone soon pasted a “50%” where CNN's “40%” had been, and the crudely doctored freeze frame began to spread across the Trump Internet.
“Trumps doing big things people! No one can take him down!” wrote an Instagram user who shared the image several hours before it ended up on Trump Jr.'s page, in front of his 1.2 million followers.
“Amazing,” Trump Jr. wrote. “I guess there is a magic wand to make things happen and @realdonaldtrump seems to have it. #MAGA #amreicafirst.”
The initial surge of comments that followed Trump Jr.'s post were overwhelmingly positive — Trump fans thrilled at the president's inflated approval rate.
But within minutes, people began to inform Trump Jr. that something was wrong.
“Yes, that 'magic wand' is Photoshop's Magic Wand tool,” chrisconradie1 wrote to Trump Jr., referring to the software of choice for fake photo makers. Re-creation below:
(Re-creation/Adobe Photoshop/The Washington Post)
Quite a few people noticed that this wasn't even a quality hoax.
The "50%” was misaligned with the text on the original CNN graphic, and its background was a different shade of red. Also, by zooming in one could see that the original "40%” was still visible underneath the fake number.
It's still unclear how Trump Jr. found the fake image, or why he decided to share it, or left it up for a day and a half. Neither he nor a representative responded to questions from The Washington Post sent Friday morning — but by mid afternoon the bogus image had disappeared from his Instagram account.
The articles has been updated since Trump Jr. removed the image.
Read more:
Trump’s comparison of his popularity to Obama’s is less wrong than it used to be
A Reddit user who wrote about stabbing Muslims is claiming credit for Trump’s CNN video
The Trump presidency: 544 days of weird glowing orb photos
Avi Selk is a general assignment reporter for The Washington Post. He previously worked for the Dallas Morning News.
Democracy Dies in Darkness
