Fellow Bucks, I’m wanting to surprise the wife with a 10 year anniversary trip. She loves the clear blue water of the Caribbean, but we don’t have passports and if we get them that would ruin the surprise. So I’m limited to the US Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico ( if there’s any open) or the Keys. Any recommendations from experience? We prefer semi private, low key, and relaxing. I know the Florida Keys can be a party spot at times. Thanks for any input!